Support inbox transitioning through Aug 26 — for immediate response, email andrewjgaber@gmail.com meanwhile.
Skip to main content
Part of Digital Empire
Section 232 Inclusion Rebuttal Comment Template · v0 attorney-review-pending

Heat-exchange-unit parts -- Section 232 Inclusion Rebuttal Comment Template

HTSUS 8419 · Proposed rate: 25% · 10-section 5 U.S.C. § 553(c) filing shape (~1195 words).

Different from a comment letter? Yes -- a comment letter is public input on a proposed derivative-article inclusion. An inclusion rebuttal comment is a product-specific tariff waiver under 5 U.S.C. § 553(c). See our companion Heat-exchange-unit parts comment-letter template for the public-comment filing shape, or read the full Section 232 Inclusion Rebuttal complete guide for the post-Feb-2025 framework and ten-section evidentiary structure.
Want us to prepare + file this inclusion rebuttal comment for you? Our $99 inclusion-rebuttal preparation service handles the 10-section drafting, HTSUS 8-10 digit verification, domestic-supplier check documentation, and regulations.gov Docket BIS-2026-15961 submission on your behalf. Submitted within 48 business hours (usually same-day). File this inclusion rebuttal comment for me — $99 →

1. Commenter Identification (5 U.S.C. § 553(c))

Company: [Company legal name] Address: [Company registered address] EIN: [Federal Employer Identification Number] Primary contact: [Primary contact name], [Primary contact title] Email: [Primary contact email] · Phone: [Primary contact phone] Filed via regulations.gov Docket BIS-2026-15961 pursuant to the FR 2026-15961 public-comment framework.

2. HTSUS Classification + Product Description

HTSUS subheading: [HTSUS 8-10 digit subheading] [Detailed product description] Provide for each component: OEM part number, OEM manufacturer name (Alfa Laval, Kelvion, SWEP, Danfoss, Modine, API Heat Transfer, Xylem, Chart Industries, etc.), HTSUS 8-10 digit subheading, parent heat-exchanger model and duty class, material composition (aluminum 3003/6061/6063 finstock and tube alloys; stainless 304L/316L for plates; copper-nickel 90/10 or 70/30 for marine tubing), ASME Section VIII pressure-vessel stamp reference where applicable, AHRI performance-rating certificate reference, and dimensional and surface-finish specifications. Attach OEM parts-catalog page, material test report format, and the ASME U-stamp or AHRI certification document.

3. Domestic-Supply Reality Check (why the inclusion criterion (iii) domestic-capacity finding does not support adding this article)

OEM-parts capacity analysis: whether any U.S.-based heat-exchanger component manufacturer can produce the exact OEM-specified replacement part at the OEM's ASME or AHRI performance standard and material specification, not whether a generic heat-exchanger part is available. Contact each U.S.-based heat-exchanger OEM (Alfa Laval U.S., Modine Manufacturing, API Heat Transfer, Chart Industries, Xylem, Bell & Gossett, Armstrong International) and independent U.S.-based finstock and coil producers (Aerofin, Colmac Coil, Super Radiator Coils). Document each response. Reference U.S. Census Bureau NAICS 333415 (Air-Conditioning, Warm-Air Heating Equipment, and Commercial and Industrial Refrigeration Equipment Manufacturing) annual domestic-production statistics and the Air-Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (AHRI) member and certification directories at ahrinet.org.

4. National-Security Counter-Argument (why the inclusion criterion (i) national-security nexus is weak or absent)

Heat-exchanger equipment supports commercial and industrial cooling and refrigeration infrastructure -- data-center cooling, food-cold-chain refrigeration, industrial process heat transfer, and building HVAC. Where the specific components service defense-related installations (DoD facilities, defense-critical data-center cooling, cold-chain logistics for defense medical supply), cite the specific program or contract. For commercial-only end use, base the request on criterion (v) 'other information the commenter believes relevant' of Federal Register notice 2026-15961's public-comment invitation: heat-exchanger downtime cascades into food-safety, data-center-uptime, and industrial-process risk categories that operate against the underlying policy purpose. Reference the Department of Energy's Critical Materials Assessment 2023 discussion of copper-nickel and specialty aluminum in industrial heat transfer.

5. Domestic Supplier Contact Log + Response Documentation

[Domestic suppliers contacted with dates] Written inquiry to each U.S.-based heat-exchanger OEM and independent finstock/coil producer identified above, plus to the AHRI Certification Program listings for the specific product category. For plate-and-frame components (Alfa Laval, SWEP, Kelvion, GEA), specify the exact plate pattern, gasket compound, and duty pressure -- generic 'plate heat exchanger' is not a sufficient inquiry. 30-day minimum response window. Objectors have 30 days from posting of this rebuttal comment on regulations.gov to file counter-comments; Modine, Aerofin, and Colmac Coil are likely respondents for finstock and coil assemblies. Retain all correspondence in the inclusion-rebuttal file.

6. Economic Impact of Proposed Inclusion (downstream customer harm quantified)

Quantify the 25 percent duty pass-through on [Annual customs value USD] at HTSUS [HTSUS 8-10 digit subheading] to downstream customers: HVAC service contractors, industrial process operators, cold-chain operators, and data-center facilities. Include: (i) 12-month CBP entry summaries; (ii) downstream customer segment analysis (percent to service-and-repair, percent to OEM-replacement, percent to new-installation); (iii) projected equipment-downtime multiplier when replacement parts run 12-16 additional weeks of lead time from re-sourcing effort; (iv) documented projection of downstream project pricing impact.

7. Alternative Sourcing Considerations (why substitution is not commercially available)

Identify whether OEM-specification heat-exchanger components are available from producers in any country not subject to the proposed Section 232 rate. Specialty heat-exchanger production is globally concentrated in a small number of source countries per OEM -- Sweden and Germany for plate-and-frame, Japan and Korea for brazed-aluminum finstock, and China for commodity coil production. Where alternate sourcing exists, document landed-cost comparison, ASME/AHRI qualification status of the alternate producer, and lead-time impact.

8. Precedent Citations (prior BIS derivative-article rulemakings where inclusion was declined or narrowed)

1. BIS Section 232 Exclusion Portal, historical determinations addressing OEM-specific precision heat-transfer components across HVAC and industrial-process categories (searchable public docket, regulations.gov (Docket BIS-2026-15961)). 2. Commerce Department Section 232 steel report, January 11, 2018, at 45-52 (methodology for evaluating specialty derivative components at the product-specification level). 3. the public comment mechanism established by Federal Register notice 2026-15961 (August 6, 2026), operative under the notice-and-comment rulemaking framework of 5 U.S.C. § 553(c); criterion (v) 'other information the commenter believes relevant' of Federal Register notice 2026-15961's public-comment invitation (adverse-effect-on-domestic-industrial-capex basis). 4. Federal Register notice 2026-15961 (August 6, 2026), criteria (iii) domestic-capacity and (iv) downstream-employment. 5. ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section VIII, Division 1 (Rules for Construction of Pressure Vessels); AHRI Standard 400 (Performance Rating of Liquid to Liquid Heat Exchangers), AHRI Standard 410 (Forced-Circulation Air-Cooling and Air-Heating Coils). 6. U.S. Census Bureau NAICS 333415 domestic manufacturing statistics; Air-Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (AHRI) Certification Program annual directories.

9. Executive Summary of Opposition to Proposed Inclusion

This public comment is submitted in opposition to the proposed Section 232 derivative-article inclusion of parts of heat-exchange units (HTSUS heading 8419.50 and parts subheading 8419.90) contemplated by Federal Register notice 2026-15961. [Company legal name] requests a product-specific exclusion for OEM-specific heat-exchanger replacement components -- brazed-aluminum finstock and coil assemblies, stainless-steel plate-and-frame gaskets and plates, copper-nickel tubing bundles, and specialty condenser/evaporator sub-assemblies -- sold under an OEM part number for HVAC and industrial process equipment already installed and in service in United States commercial, industrial, and refrigeration applications. Heat-exchanger replacement components are OEM-qualified against tight ASME Section VIII pressure-vessel or AHRI performance-rating specifications and cannot be substituted without a full requalification cycle. We request an 18-month exclusion covering the specific HTSUS subheadings identified below. Requested transition-and-adjustment period if BIS proceeds with inclusion: [Requested transition-and-adjustment period if BIS proceeds with inclusion - typically 12 months] months.

10. Attestation + Signature Block + Not-Legal-Advice Disclaimer

Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1001 (false statements to a federal agency) and the identification requirements of 5 U.S.C. § 553(c), I attest that the statements in this comment are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge, and that I am authorized to submit this comment on behalf of [Company legal name]. _________________________________ [Primary contact name], [Primary contact title] [Company legal name] [Primary contact email] · [Primary contact phone] Submitted via regulations.gov Docket BIS-2026-15961: 2026-08-26 --- **Draft Status: v0 -- attorney-review-pending.** This template was auto-generated by TariffWatch from Federal Register notice 2026-15961, Presidential Proclamations 10895 and 10896 (Feb 10, 2025 -- terminating the 15 CFR § 705.5 exclusion-request process), and publicly available BIS Section 232 rulemaking materials. Not legal advice, not customs classification advice under 19 CFR 111. Consult qualified counsel or a licensed customs broker before submitting to regulations.gov Docket BIS-2026-15961. Every substantive claim in this request that is factual to your business -- HTSUS subheading, annual quantity, annual customs value, cost-impact projections, sourcing country, domestic-supplier contacts -- must be verified by the submitter before filing. TariffWatch (Digital Empire Holdings LLC) makes no representation as to the sufficiency of this request for any specific regulatory outcome.

How to submit

  1. Register a filing account at the regulations.gov Docket BIS-2026-15961.
  2. Copy the sections above into the portal's structured filing form (each portal field maps 1:1 to a numbered section here).
  3. Attach supporting exhibits (import records, spec sheets, domestic-supplier contact log, cost-impact projection).
  4. Submit and monitor the 30-day public-docket objection window; be ready to respond to objectors within the portal's response window.